TLDR
Montclair is an excellent choice for NYC commuters who want walkable downtown living, top-rated schools, and cultural life without Manhattan prices. Median home price ~$850K. Commute to Penn Station: 45–55 min by NJ Transit. Property taxes are high (~$20–25K/year for a typical home).
Moving to Montclair NJ: Complete 2026 Relocation Guide
Montclair consistently ranks as one of the best towns in New Jersey — and for good reason. But it's also one of the most expensive, with some of the highest property taxes in the state. This guide gives you the honest picture so you can decide if it's the right fit before you start bidding on houses.
Montclair at a Glance
Population
~39,000
County
Essex County, NJ
Commute to NYC
45–55 min
Median Home Price
~$850,000
Avg. Property Tax
$20,000–$25,000/yr
School Rating
Above average (8–9/10)
Montclair is a township in Essex County, about 15 miles west of Midtown Manhattan. It's known for its walkable downtown along Bloomfield Avenue, strong arts and culture scene (Montclair Art Museum, Wellmont Theater), diverse dining, and highly regarded public schools.
The community is notably diverse — racially, politically, economically. This mix is both Montclair's greatest asset and occasionally a source of tension, particularly around school equity debates. People who move here generally love it, but it's not for everyone.
Montclair Neighborhoods
South End
$650K–$900K typicalMost walkable to downtown Bloomfield Ave. Smaller homes, more modest prices relative to Montclair. Strong community feel. Most convenient for train commuters (Bay Street station).
Center / Midtown
$800K–$1.2M typicalNear Lackawanna Plaza and the Wellmont Theater. A mix of housing styles, close to Watchung Plaza. Very walkable.
Upper Montclair
$1M–$2M+ typicalMore suburban, quieter. Larger lots and homes. Upper Montclair Station on the Montclair-Boonton line. Top-rated elementary schools. The go-to for families with kids.
Watchung / West End
$600K–$900K typicalBorders Verona and West Orange. Slightly more affordable entry point into Montclair. Easy access to Eagle Rock Reservation.
The NYC Commute
The commute is the #1 factor for most people evaluating Montclair. Here's the honest picture:
By NJ Transit Rail
Montclair has 3 train stations: Bay Street, Watchung Ave, and Upper Montclair, all on the Montclair-Boonton Line. From Bay Street to Penn Station: approximately 47–55 minutes depending on whether you take the direct train or require a transfer at Newark Broad Street.
Monthly NJ Transit pass from Montclair to NYC: approximately $250–$280/month. Parking at Bay Street station (the most convenient) is competitive — there are wait lists for monthly permits.
By Car
Driving to Manhattan during peak hours is variable but expect 60–90 minutes in traffic. The Lincoln Tunnel via Route 3 or the George Washington Bridge via Route 46 are the primary routes.
By Bus
NJ Transit buses run along Bloomfield Avenue into Port Authority. Express buses take approximately 45 minutes to Midtown in the morning. This is the cheapest option (~$5 each way).
Montclair Schools
The public school system is a major draw — and also one of the most complex and debated aspects of living in Montclair. The district uses a magnet school system where elementary students attend schools outside their immediate neighborhood based on selected programs.
Key Facts
- Montclair High School consistently ranks among the top public high schools in NJ
- AP course offerings are extensive; many students graduate with college credits
- The magnet system means your child may be bused to a school not in your immediate area
- Strong arts and athletics programs at all levels
- Several highly regarded private school options as well: Lacordaire, Montclair Kimberley Academy
The school quality is why Upper Montclair commands premium pricing — the elementary schools in that area are consistently top-rated.
Cost of Living in Montclair
Montclair is expensive. The property taxes are the primary sticker shock for newcomers:
| Home Price | Estimated Annual Tax | Monthly Tax |
|---|---|---|
| $650,000 | ~$16,000–$19,000 | ~$1,375 |
| $850,000 | ~$20,000–$24,000 | ~$1,833 |
| $1,200,000 | ~$26,000–$32,000 | ~$2,417 |
| $1,800,000 | ~$35,000–$45,000 | ~$3,333 |
New Jersey has some of the highest property taxes in the country and Montclair is above the state average. Factor this into your full monthly housing cost calculation alongside mortgage, insurance, and utilities.
Honest Pros and Cons
✅ Why People Love It
- Genuine walkable downtown with character
- Excellent restaurants and nightlife for a suburb
- Top-tier public schools
- Active arts and culture scene
- Diverse, engaged community
- Strong sense of neighborhood identity
- Manageable NYC commute by train
- Close to Eagle Rock Reservation for nature
⚠️ The Real Talk
- Property taxes are brutal — $20–25K/year is typical
- Home prices have risen significantly since 2020
- Parking is challenging near downtown
- School assignment/magnet system frustrates some families
- NJ Transit reliability is inconsistent
- Strong opinions on everything — community meetings can be intense
- Limited inventory — homes sell fast and often over asking
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Montclair NJ safe?
Montclair is generally very safe. Crime rates are low compared to urban areas. Like any town, some areas are quieter than others, but safety is rarely a primary concern for residents.
Is Montclair worth it for the commute?
Most commuters say yes — the quality of life in Montclair justifies the commute. The train ride is comfortable and direct trains run regularly during peak hours.
How is the food scene in Montclair?
Excellent for a suburb. Bloomfield Avenue has restaurants spanning Ethiopian, Italian, Japanese, Latin, American, and more. The bar and cocktail scene is also strong.
What's the best neighborhood in Montclair for families?
Upper Montclair is consistently recommended for families with children due to its highly rated elementary schools, larger homes, and quieter residential feel.
How competitive is the Montclair real estate market?
Very competitive. Homes that are priced correctly typically receive multiple offers within a week. Budget for bidding over asking price in desirable neighborhoods.
Find Local Services in Montclair
From plumbers to landscapers to electricians — find trusted local professionals.
Browse the Directory